The One Hit Wonderers

ONE HIT WONDERERS present: "I love That Song!"

With their Musical Revue of the New American Songbook 60s, 70s, & 80s, The One Hit Wonderers celebrate the unforgettable tunes left behind by artists who had their moment in the spotlight before vanishing into history. These musicians may have only delivered one smash hit, but their songs remain timeless, and this band is dedicated to keeping them alive.

When seasoned musicians come together with a shared passion, something extraordinary happens. The One Hit Wonderers are a tribute to these one-hit wonders, and their members boast an impressive history of performing alongside rock legends—Chuck Berry, The Who’s Roger Daltrey, Loggins and Messina, and the incomparable Aretha Franklin. Their experience spans genres, having collaborated with jazz greats like Wynton Marsalis, Larry Coryell, and Victor Wooten, as well as classical icon Leonard Bernstein.

These accomplished musicians, who have stood onstage with legends, now bring you the songs that defined generations. They’ll fill your heart with joy and have you singing along to the hits you’ve loved for years. The music you dance to, the songs you belt out in the car—it’s all here, ready to transport you to cherished memories.

Sonoma Beach Productions proudly presents “I Love That Song,” an original musical theater experience led by composer and multi-instrumentalist Gary Oleyar of Sonoma Beach Productions, LLC. Featuring an incredible lineup of musicians and vocalists, The One Hit Wonderers bring the iconic hits of the 60s, 70s, and 80s to life. The band is comprised of Gary Oleyar (Guitar, Violin, Vocals), Kevin Brennan (Lead Vocals), Andy Huenerberg (Bass), John Colaiacovo (Keyboards), Sam Bryant (Drums) and more!

Get ready for a show that will have you dancing, singing, and reminiscing about the songs that never fade. Immerse yourself in nostalgia, revel in the excitement, and feel the magic of “I Love That Song!”

Artist Website



Planning on seeing your favorite artist at Sellersville Theater? Why not make a night of it? Use promo code SHOW15 when booking online or by phone at The Washington House Hotel, right next door (215-257-3000). One promo code can be used for each night’s stay.

A processing fee of $7 per ticket will appear on your order at check out. This fee is waived when you purchase in person at our Box Office, click here for hours.

The cabaret and through row D are reserved for Theater Members until one month before the show. To inquire about Membership, call our Box Office at 215-257-5808 or click here. If you are a Theater Member, select your tickets using the price code that matches your Membership level and enter your Member ID into the Membership box on the checkout page.

Friends & Fanatics: Thank you for your support! As promised, you do not pay additional ticket fees. Because we are unable to remove fees from online sales, we lower the ticket price you see below by $7 so that when the fee is applied it all balances out and you pay the original ticket price, nothing more! Please call the Box Office with questions at 215-257-5808.